What is the difference between a freestanding and an attached deck?
The difference is what holds up the edge of the deck closest to the house. On an attached deck, that edge rests on a ledger board bolted through the house's band joist, so the house carries part of the deck's weight. On a freestanding deck, a second beam on its own posts and footings runs a few inches off the wall, and the house carries none of it.
Most of the other differences follow from that one decision. An attached deck needs one fewer row of footings, but it puts fasteners and flashing through the house wall and has to be tied back against sideways movement. A freestanding deck leaves the wall alone, but adds posts and footings close to the foundation, in soil that was dug out and refilled when the house went up.
The code is strict about the house connection. Section R507.8 of the 2018 IRC, which Idaho adopted with state amendments as its residential code, does not allow a deck to be attached with toenails or with nails loaded in withdrawal. It also says that where a positive connection to the house can't be verified during inspection, the deck has to be self-supporting. Put plainly, a deck only counts as attached when an inspector can confirm lags or bolts through a proper ledger into sound house framing. Anything short of that has to hold itself up.

A freestanding deck doesn't have to look detached. The gap at the wall is usually small, and the boards can run up close to it. The change is underneath, where a beam and a row of posts take the place of the ledger.
How does attaching a deck change the permit?
In some Treasure Valley cities the house connection is itself a permit trigger, and in others only height counts. The cities don't agree, which is why this design choice changes paperwork here more than it would in most places.
Meridian is the clearest example. A March 17, 2021 memo from the city's Building Official, included in its detached accessory structures handout, says any deck attached to the house needs a permit, because anything that isn't detached counts as an addition under the IRC. Height doesn't matter for an attached deck. The handout's exemption #7 applies to detached decks only, and only when the deck is 200 square feet or smaller, no more than 30 inches above grade, and not serving the exit door required by IRC R311.4. Even an exempt detached deck still has to meet setbacks and any HOA rules, the handout notes.
Kuna lists two separate triggers on its residential building page: decks more than 30 inches above grade, and any structure attached to the house. A low deck bolted to a Kuna house needs a permit because of the connection. A freestanding deck 30 inches high or lower doesn't hit either of the triggers the city lists.
Boise and Nampa look at height alone, and they draw the line lower than the model code does. Boise's residential construction guide requires a permit for any deck more than 12 inches above grade, and Nampa's residential FAQ uses the same 12-inch line. In those two cities, a freestanding deck 18 inches off the ground needs a permit exactly as an attached one would. Going freestanding there changes what the drawings show, not whether you file.
Star's building FAQ requires a permit for decks 30 inches or more above grade and lists no separate trigger for attached decks. Caldwell's inspections page says additions, porches, carports and decks require separate permits and inspections, with no height cutoff given on that page. Eagle, Garden City, Middleton and unincorporated Ada County don't publish a deck threshold on any page we have read, so call the building department before treating a small deck as exempt.
| Jurisdiction | Attached deck | Freestanding deck |
|---|---|---|
| Meridian | Permit at any height | Permit if over 200 sq ft, over 30 in, more than one story or serving the exit door |
| Kuna | Permit (any attached structure) | Permit over 30 in |
| Boise | Permit over 12 in | Permit over 12 in |
| Nampa | Permit over 12 in | Permit over 12 in |
| Star | Permit at 30 in or more | Permit at 30 in or more |
| Caldwell | Decks need separate permits | Decks need separate permits |
| Canyon County (unincorporated) | 2011 guide: over 30 in (dated) | 2011 guide: over 30 in (dated); ask whether the 3-ft BOD rule applies |
| Eagle / Garden City / Middleton / unincorporated Ada | Threshold not published | Threshold not published |
The full rule, submittal list and phone numbers for each city are on our permit pages: Meridian's attached-deck rule, Kuna deck permits, the Boise 12-inch threshold, Nampa's deck permit page, Star's 30-inch rule, Caldwell deck permits, Eagle's submittal checklist and Garden City's permit process.
Freestanding vs attached at a glance
This table sets the two designs side by side on the points that settle most Treasure Valley projects.
| Factor | Attached deck | Freestanding deck |
|---|---|---|
| House connection | Ledger bolted to the band joist, flashed | None; its own beam line at the house side |
| Lateral load (IRC) | Hold-downs: 2 at 1,500 lb or more, or 4 at 750 lb or more | Self-supporting framing |
| Stone or masonry veneer | Ledger not allowed on veneer | Avoids the issue |
| Pier-block option | No | Only at 200 sq ft or less and 20 in or less, joists on precast piers |
| Meridian permit | Always | Exempt only if 200 sq ft or less, 30 in or less, not at the exit door |
| Kuna permit | Always | Over 30 in |
| Manufactured home (Caldwell) | No structural attachment | Required approach |
When can a freestanding deck skip frost footings?
Only when it's small, low and built one particular way. IRC R507.3.2 lets a freestanding deck skip footings below the frost line when its joists bear directly on precast concrete pier blocks with no beams or posts, the deck covers 200 square feet or less, and the walking surface is no more than 20 inches above grade.
Every one of those conditions has to hold. Once the design adds a beam on posts, even short ones, the exception is gone and each post needs a footing below frost. Attached decks don't qualify at all. A ledger on a house sitting on frost-depth foundations, paired with outer blocks that ride up and down with the ground, is the mismatch the frost rule exists to prevent.
Outside that exception, footings go below the frost line, and across the valley that line is 24 inches. Boise's current-codes page lists a 24-inch frost depth, as do Star's and Caldwell's published design criteria and Canyon County's design table for unincorporated land. Meridian's handout calls for footings to the frost line, 24 inches deep. Middleton's design criteria say 24 inches or as a geotechnical soils report directs.
The reason is winter. NOAA's 1991–2020 normals for the Boise Air Terminal count 108 nights a year at or below freezing, and Boise's design criteria list an air freezing index of 894. Soil that freezes and thaws that often lifts shallow concrete a little with each cycle. A deck sitting on blocks moves along with it, which is tolerable on a 20-inch platform with no house connection and nothing rigid to crack.
The pier-block exception covers footings, not permits. In Boise and Nampa a block-supported deck more than 12 inches above grade still needs a permit, so a 20-inch deck on blocks there is a permitted deck that simply doesn't need frost footings. In Meridian, a block deck that stays detached, at or under 200 square feet and 30 inches high, and away from the required exit door can fit exemption #7.
Once a design needs real footings, our deck footing depth guide covers sizing and pier types, and ground-level deck ideas shows the low designs where the pier-block route can work.
What does the code ask of an attached deck's ledger?
A ledger has to bolt into the house's actual framing, stay flashed, and carry only joists, never a beam. The 2018 IRC sets those limits in R507.9.1 and R507.9.2; here is the short version.
- No veneer. R507.9.1 doesn't allow a deck ledger to be supported on stone or masonry veneer.
- Full bearing. The house band joist the ledger fastens to has to bear fully on the primary structure, which has to be able to carry the load.
- No point loads. Beams and girders can't hang from a ledger; it carries joists only.
- Corrosion-resistant fasteners. Lag screws and bolts are hot-dipped galvanized or stainless steel, with spacing taken from Table R507.9.1.3(1).
- Flashing. The connection is flashed so water can't sit between the ledger and the band joist.
- Lateral hold-downs. R507.9.2 gives two prescriptive ways to keep the deck from pulling away sideways: two hold-down devices rated at least 1,500 pounds each, within 24 inches of each end of the deck, or four rated at least 750 pounds.
The ledger fastener table assumes a 40 psf live load, a 10 psf dead load and a snow load of 40 psf or less that isn't applied at the same time as the live load. Boise's design ground snow load is 20 psf, inside that envelope. The American Wood Council's DCA 6 guide leaves hot tubs out of its prescriptive details, and a roof over the deck adds loads the ledger table doesn't account for, so either one usually means an engineered design; ask the building department before assuming otherwise.
Plan reviewers expect to see this detail drawn. Boise's #402 checklist calls for ledger connection details, its #406 checklist for additions and accessory structures asks for a framing plan, elevations and a section from footing to rail, and Eagle's residential checklist asks for deck location, construction and ledger details. Our ledger repair guide covers failures, fastener patterns and what a sound connection looks like on an older deck.
| Jurisdiction | Asks for or shows |
|---|---|
| Boise #402 | Ledger connection details; site plan with distances to property lines |
| Boise #406 | Framing plan, elevations, footing-to-rail section; stamped engineering for decks more than 6 ft above grade |
| Eagle | Deck location, construction and ledger details |
| Caldwell DWG 12-06 | Joists in hangers or on a 1½-in ledger; 24-in footings |
| Canyon County Tip Sheet 4 (2011) | Site plan and framing layout |
When does the house force a freestanding design?
When the wall at the deck line can't take a code-compliant ledger, the plan reviewer will accept a self-supporting deck or an engineered alternative, and nothing in between. Four situations account for most of these.
- Stone or masonry veneer where the deck meets the house. Veneer is a facing, not structure, and R507.9.1 rules out a ledger on it. The deck gets its own beam line unless an engineered connection to the framing behind the veneer is designed and approved.
- A band joist that doesn't bear fully on the structure below. A cantilevered floor or a bay projection hangs past the foundation, so a ledger fastened there fails the full-bearing rule.
- A connection nobody can verify. If the inspector can't confirm that the fasteners reach sound framing, R507.8 requires the deck to be self-supporting.
- A manufactured home. Caldwell's own handout bars structural attachment, which the next section covers.
Replacement projects add a fifth case. On an older house, the rim joist behind an old ledger is where rot tends to show up first, because that is where water collected for years. If tearing off the old deck turns up soft framing, the options are to repair the house framing before a new ledger goes on, or to carry the new deck on a beam line of its own and leave the damaged rim for a separate repair.
Height matters too, though less than people expect. A freestanding deck 8 feet up needs its house-side posts to be as tall as the outer ones, and the post-height limits in IRC Table R507.4 apply to all of them. Taller decks also run into Boise's #406 requirement for stamped engineering above 6 feet, whichever way the deck is supported.
Manufactured homes: freestanding by rule
A deck beside a manufactured home is built to stand on its own around the valley. Caldwell writes the rule down, Garden City adds an engineering requirement, and the other jurisdictions we cover say less.
Caldwell's Typical Porch/Deck Section handout, drawing DWG 12-06, carries a note for manufactured homes. A porch or carport may be attached only with a design by a licensed design professional, the roof covering is the only part permitted to attach, and the sheet states that no structural attachment is allowed. For a deck, that means its own posts, beam and 24-inch footings running alongside the home, with the deck framing held clear of the home itself.
Garden City's residential permit application says every alteration to a manufactured home has to be submitted with plans stamped by an engineer. Fastening a deck or entry landing to the home is likely to count as an alteration, so a connection to the home can turn a simple deck permit into an engineered one. A self-supporting deck set just off the home keeps the work off the home, which is the more straightforward path to take to the city's reviewers.
In unincorporated Canyon County we haven't found a rule written specifically for decks at manufactured homes. Ask the county building department before you design one, and read the next section, because the county's 3-foot rule for exempt detached structures can come up on rural lots.
At the door, the deck still meets the threshold. The landing sits at the right height on its own framing, close to the wall, without fasteners into the home. Submittal details for both cities are on the Caldwell deck permit page and the Garden City deck permit page.
Does Canyon County's 3-foot rule affect a freestanding deck?
It might, so ask before you settle the layout. Canyon County's Building Official Determination BOD-07-18-25-01, dated July 18, 2025, says structures exempt from a permit under IRC R105.2 item 1, which covers detached accessory structures of 200 square feet or less, must also sit at least 3 feet from the residence and from other accessory structures.
The determination gives two reasons: these structures aren't structurally attached, and drifting snow piles up in the narrow gap between buildings set close together. It is written for exempt detached accessory structures such as sheds. Whether the county applies it to a low freestanding deck a few inches off the house is a question for the county's building department, and the answer moves the deck, so get it early.
The county's older guidance is dated but still useful background. Its 2011 reference guide, written before the current code, says decks more than 30 inches above grade need a permit, exempts decks 30 inches or lower that aren't over a basement or story below, and exempts replacing deck boards when no structural members are replaced. Tip Sheet 4 on basic decks asks for a site plan and a framing layout. Confirm the current rule with the county before relying on any of it.
Canyon County's design table for unincorporated land uses a 25 psf ground snow load and a 24-inch frost depth, a little heavier on snow than Boise's 20 psf. That difference doesn't change the freestanding-or-attached decision, but it does show up in the framing plan.
Which one costs more?
Neither design is reliably cheaper, and we don't publish a dollar difference because no source we trust measures one. What differs is the parts list, and which list is longer depends on the deck.
- An attached deck adds a ledger board, lag screws or through-bolts sized from the IRC table, metal or approved flashing at the wall, and lateral hold-down hardware. Flashing a ledger correctly also means opening the wall's weather barrier at the rim and lapping it back.
- A freestanding deck adds a beam, a row of posts and a row of footings along the house, dug to the same 24-inch frost depth as the others and placed so they don't bear on loose backfill next to the foundation.
On a low, wide deck, the extra row of footings is a modest share of the job. On a tall deck, the house-side posts are as long as the rest, while ledger work stays about the same size. On an older house, opening the wall can turn up rim repairs that change the comparison entirely.
To see how size, height and material move a budget, try the deck cost calculator. The Boise deck cost guide lays out published third-party price ranges with their sources and dates.
How we choose between freestanding and attached
We decide from the house and the city's rules, then draw whichever detail fits. The checks run in this order.
- Look at the wall where the deck meets the house: framed and clad, stone or brick veneer, a cantilevered floor or a bay. Veneer or a cantilever points to freestanding.
- Find the band joist from the crawlspace or basement where we can, and confirm it bears on the foundation and is sound enough to carry a ledger.
- Check which door the deck serves. In Meridian, a deck at the exit door required by R311.4 needs a permit whatever its size.
- Measure the height. Over 12 inches in Boise and Nampa, over 30 inches in Kuna and 30 inches or more in Star, height settles the permit question.
- Apply the city's attached-deck rule. In Meridian and Kuna, connecting to the house means a permit at any height.
- Read the HOA rules. CC&Rs can limit placement, size and materials whichever way the deck is supported.
- Ask about a cover later. A roof or pergola added to an attached deck puts new load on the ledger and the house wall, while one on a freestanding deck lands on its own posts.
The framing plan then shows one of two details: the ledger with its fasteners, flashing and hold-downs, or the self-supporting beam line along the house with its posts and footings. If a cover is likely, check the city's patio-cover and pergola rules before choosing, since they differ from city to city. HOA timing is covered in the HOA deck approval guide. To start, request an estimate or see how our custom deck building work runs.
Shortcuts to avoid
These are the shortcuts a plan reviewer or inspector will flag, listed so you can spot them in a bid. None of this is a how-to.
- Toenailing or face-nailing a deck to the house. R507.8 rules out nails loaded in withdrawal, and once those nails work loose, nothing holds the deck to the wall.
- Bolting a ledger through stone veneer. The veneer isn't structure, and R507.9.1 doesn't allow it.
- Calling a bolted deck freestanding to stay under Meridian's or Kuna's attached-deck rule. If it's tied to the house, it's attached.
- Pier blocks under a deck more than 20 inches high, larger than 200 square feet, or framed with beams and posts. The R507.3.2 exception doesn't stretch to cover any of them.
- Any structural tie to a manufactured home in Caldwell, or an unstamped one in Garden City.
- Tucking an exempt detached structure closer than 3 feet to the house in unincorporated Canyon County without asking how BOD-07-18-25-01 applies.
- Hanging a beam off the ledger to save a post. Point loads on a ledger aren't allowed.
- Leaving lateral hold-downs off an attached deck because the old deck never had them.
Related resources
The ledger itself, including rot, fasteners and repair, is covered in our deck ledger board guide. Framing sizes for either design come from the IRC's joist and beam span tables, and footing depth and diameter are explained in the Boise footing guide. Lots with a ditch or canal behind them have their own rules in building near an irrigation easement. Shape and flow ideas are in deck layout ideas, and the city with the strictest attached-deck rule is covered on the Meridian deck permit page.
Frequently asked questions
- Does a freestanding deck need a permit in Meridian?
- Sometimes. Meridian's accessory structures handout exempts a detached deck only when it is 200 square feet or smaller, no more than 30 inches above grade and not serving the exit door required by IRC R311.4. A freestanding deck that misses any of those limits needs a permit. Setbacks and HOA rules still apply to an exempt deck, and any deck attached to the house needs a permit at any height.
- Does a freestanding deck need a permit in Boise?
- Yes, if it stands more than 12 inches above grade. Boise's residential construction guide sets the permit line at 12 inches for decks and concrete patios, and it doesn't distinguish freestanding from attached. A freestanding design changes what the drawings show, a beam line instead of a ledger detail, but a deck above 12 inches goes through review either way.
- Can a deck ledger be attached over stone veneer?
- No. Section R507.9.1 of the 2018 IRC, which Idaho has adopted, does not allow a deck ledger to be supported on stone or masonry veneer, because veneer is a facing rather than structure. Where veneer covers the wall at the deck line, the deck needs its own beam line on posts and footings, or an engineered connection that the building department approves.
- Can a freestanding deck sit on pier blocks?
- Only a small, low one. IRC R507.3.2 allows precast pier blocks instead of frost-depth footings when the deck is freestanding, its joists bear directly on the blocks with no beams or posts, it covers 200 square feet or less and the walking surface is no more than 20 inches above grade. Anything larger, taller or framed on posts needs footings below the 24-inch frost line.
- Can I attach a deck to a manufactured home in Caldwell?
- Not structurally. Caldwell's Typical Porch/Deck Section handout, DWG 12-06, says the roof covering is the only part that may attach to a manufactured home, that a porch or carport attachment needs a licensed design professional's design, and that no structural attachment is allowed. A deck there stands on its own posts, beam and 24-inch footings beside the home.
- How deep do freestanding deck footings go in the Treasure Valley?
- Usually 24 inches, the same as any other deck footing. Boise, Star, Caldwell and unincorporated Canyon County all list a 24-inch frost depth, Meridian's handout calls for footings to the frost line at 24 inches, and Middleton says 24 inches or as a soils report directs. The only exception is a small, low freestanding deck on precast pier blocks.
Sources
- City of Meridian — Residential Detached Accessory Structures handout (rev. 3/15/2021)
- City of Kuna — Residential Building Information (decks over 30 in, attached structures)
- City of Boise — Guide to Residential Construction (brochure, updated 5/2023)
- City of Nampa — Residential FAQ (deck height threshold)
- City of Star — Building FAQ (deck and patio cover permit triggers)
- City of Caldwell — Building Safety Division, Inspections (decks require separate permits)
- 2018 IRC as adopted in Idaho, Chapter 5 (R507 Exterior Decks) — UpCodes
- American Wood Council — DCA 6, Prescriptive Residential Wood Deck Construction Guide (2015 IRC basis)
- City of Caldwell — Typical Porch/Deck Section handout (DWG 12-06)
- Garden City — Residential Building Permit Application and Plan Checklist (4/25/2023)
- Canyon County — Building Official Determination BOD-07-18-25-01 (3-ft separation for exempt detached structures, 7/18/2025)
- Canyon County — A Reference Guide to Building in Canyon County (2011)
- Canyon County — Building Department (Table R301.2(1) design criteria)
- City of Boise — #402 New Residential Submittal Checklist (July 2024)
- City of Boise — #406 Residential Addition, Alteration & Accessory Building Submittal Checklist (July 2025)
- City of Eagle — New Residential Building/Addition Submittal Checklist (2023)
- City of Boise — 301 Current Building Codes (2018 IRC design criteria)
- City of Star — Adopted Codes & Design Criteria
- City of Caldwell — Code Resources & FAQs (adopted codes and design criteria)
- City of Middleton — Design Criteria (5/24/2024)
- NOAA NCEI U.S. Climate Normals 1991–2020, Boise Air Terminal (USW00024131) — annual/seasonal
Last reviewed .











